Sunday, September 24, 2017

Anthem Kneeling

I have seen a lot of upset posts about the protests and some standing up for the protesters, and it feels like an issue ripe for discussion. Here is my take.

It's interesting how such a thing as how you act during the national anthem is construed as a huge deal by some people. It's hard when the people kneeling in response to the anthem are millionaires who play a game for a living. As a white person living just a little above the poverty line and who has never been discriminated against because of his skin color, it's hard to connect to African-American millionaires who play a sport for money, protesting during the national anthem. However, this is an issue with multiple sides, and if I practice empathy, I realize that these men in their protest are reminding us that there is grave injustice going on on a daily basis all around us. That grown men are getting shot by the police, and then when that policeman is arrested he often gets off without a conviction- that's a big deal. If I take a moment and step into another man's shoes, I see that this injustice going on is a big deal- how can you draw attention to it? To be fair, these anthem protests are pretty effective. Without destroying property or making a street impassible by filling it with people, these athletes are drawing attention to an issue that is being somewhat ignored by White-America.

I don't know what to say- I'm conflicted. On the one hand, I'm grateful for what America has done for me. I'm painfully aware that there are many worse situations I could be in than the one I'm in. I think America is a great country. It has its faults, true, but overall I'm glad I live here. God has blessed me mightily in my life in this country. I have the freedom to make this blog and say largely whatever I want. It's a land of great opportunity, and I appreciate that. I also appreciate the fact that people died so that I could have this freedom, particularly in World War II. I have running water and food to eat. I have shelter and a place to sleep. I have a car I drive to go where I want to go, and in general I get treated well by the people I come across. I DO NOT want to come off as an ingrate to the people who populate this great country. On the other hand, grave injustice is going on in this country. African-Americans are afraid they will be shot when they come home from work by police who jumped to conclusions about their behavior. When an African-American walks around a store, sometimes it's assumed they're there to shoplift and are treated accordingly. Basically... I mean, I don't want to exaggerate what I imagine it is like for a person of color, but I have had conversations, and I know that it isn't as rosy for them as it seems to generally be for me. As a man who loves God, I'm called to care about the problems of my neighbor. How should I respond?

I'm at a loss. I'm really wrestling with how I should feel about all this. There doesn't seem to be a clear right answer as to what to say. Jesus cared a lot about strangers and about race-related issues. His story about the good Samaritan highlights that. He picked a foreigner for the hero of that story- that says something about Jesus. Here's what I can say- we as a nation would do well to consider another person's perspective. God doesn't want us divided as a nation over issues we should agree on- like whether it's okay for police to shoot African-Americans and get away with it. We should all be able to agree that that is bad. Can we agree that Colin Kaepernick has generally good reasons for protesting? Possibly, but I'm not even sure that we can all agree on that. I PERSONALLY feel that the issues being protested are far more significant than the importance of standing during the national anthem- maybe because I'm grieved over the injustice African-Americans experience on a day to day basis? Possibly. In my heart of hearts though, I wish there was a better way for these very wealthy athletes to protest what they are protesting. I think football should be football, not a forum for expressing grievances about injustice in our country.

No comments: